Spring on Long Island is prime time to set your turf up for a season of rich color and steady growth. But a few common missteps—especially in Suffolk County’s sandy/loamy soils and coastal microclimates—can undo months of progress. Below are the seven biggest spring lawn mistakes we see, why they matter locally, and exactly what to do instead for thicker, greener turf from Holbrook to Patchogue, Sayville, and beyond.
When the ground is still wet and tender from winter, aggressive raking or power cleaning tears crowns and uproots shallow roots. On Suffolk County’s often-soft spring soils, that damage shows up later as thin, patchy areas that weeds love.
Do this instead:
Wait until the lawn is fully out of dormancy and the soil is firm underfoot (no squish). Use a spring-tine rake with light pressure to lift matted areas and leftover leaves. If snow mold is present, gentle raking is enough to open the canopy and speed recovery—no heavy dethatching needed in most cases.
Scalping might feel like “resetting” the lawn for spring, but it removes stored energy and exposes soil to sunlight—inviting crabgrass and other annual weeds to germinate. Low cuts also stress cool-season grasses (fescue, bluegrass, rye) common across Long Island.
Do this instead:
Set blades to 3–3.5 inches for the first cut and 3.5–4 inches once growth is steady. Taller grass shades soil, reduces weed germination, and grows deeper roots—critical in sandy soils that dry quickly on the South Shore and central Suffolk.
Missing the pre-emergent window is one of the most expensive spring mistakes. On Long Island, soil temperature, not the calendar, dictates timing. If you apply too late, crabgrass gains a foothold that’s costly to remove all summer.
Do this instead:
Apply a quality pre-emergent when soil temps approach the mid-50s°F for several days. In Suffolk County, that’s often early to mid-spring, but it varies with weather. If you overseeded late last fall and have young grass, use a seeding-safe approach or delay in those areas per label guidance.
Chasing instant green with heavy, quick-release nitrogen causes surge growth and shallow roots, making the lawn thirsty and disease-prone by June. It also increases mowing frequency—without increasing turf quality.
Do this instead:
Choose a slow-release, balanced spring feeding with micronutrients (iron for color, potassium for resilience). This creates even growth, thicker blades, and better root development—key for drought tolerance in windy coastal zones like Bay Shore and Port Jefferson.
Frequent, shallow watering teaches roots to live near the surface. As soon as we hit a warm, breezy week, those lawns wilt first, inviting weed pressure and disease.
Do this instead:
Water deeply and infrequently—aim for 1 to 1.5 inches per week in active growth, delivered in 1–2 sessions. In spring, you may need little to no irrigation if rainfall cooperates; let the lawn tell you when it needs a deep drink. Always water early morning to reduce evaporation and disease risk.
Suffolk County soils often trend slightly acidic, which can lock up nutrients and undermine your fertilizer investment. Guessing at fertilization without soil data leads to inconsistent color and thin spots.
Do this instead:
Start spring with a soil test. Adjust pH with lime if recommended, and correct nutrient deficiencies the smart way—targeted, not guesswork. When pH is right, turf uses fertilizer efficiently, needs fewer inputs, and shows richer, longer-lasting color.
Many homeowners wait until hot weather to fix thin turf. By then, seed struggles to establish, and weeds fill the gap. Compaction from foot traffic over winter and early spring also chokes roots just as growth resumes.
Do this instead:
Plan core aeration and overseeding for the prime windows—late summer into early fall is best for Long Island, but spring aeration can still relieve compaction and set up success if your lawn is struggling now. Use region-matched seed (turf-type tall fescue blends with elite bluegrass) to improve density and disease tolerance.
Blanket herbicide treatments every time you see a dandelion aren’t necessary and can stress desirable turf. Over-application also risks runoff—never a good idea near our South Shore bays and North Shore harbors.
Do this instead:
Use a targeted, selective post-emergent on active weeds, and focus long-term on density: the best weed control is a thick, healthy lawn. Pair spot treatments with proper mowing height, consistent feeding, and overseeding to close bare areas.
If you’ve ever seen turf that peels up like a carpet in late summer, grubs were likely the culprit. Spring is the time to plan preventative grub control, not to wait for damage.
Do this instead:
Ask for a preventative program timed to Long Island beetle cycles. If you’ve had damage in past seasons—or wildlife digging—prevention is usually cheaper than repairs. Combine with balanced spring feeding for root strength that’s ready for summer.
Sandy and loamy soils drain fast and leach nutrients, coastal winds increase evaporation, and fluctuating spring temps challenge cool-season turf. That’s why slow-release nutrition, correct mowing height, smart timing, and soil-first decisions are the winning combo for Suffolk County lawns—from Holbrook and Ronkonkoma to Smithtown and Port Jefferson.
.png)
Serving Suffolk County from Holbrook with soil-first, eco-friendly turf care: fertilization, weed control, aeration & overseeding, grub prevention, and mosquito/tick treatments.
Learn More
.avif)
.avif)
